Lazada Philippines aff_i?offer_id=3127&file_id=94990&aff_id=150634 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government

normal_post - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government Author Topic: The Supreme Court commits suicide  (Read 330 times)

islander

  • SUPREME COURT
  • THE LEGEND
  • *****
  • avatar_3258_1429902436 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
  • Posts: 45441
  • medal1 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal2 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal3 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal4 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal5 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
  • If you're from Pluto, you're welcome.
    • Share Post
xx - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
The Supreme Court commits suicide
« on: May 15, 2018, 08:27:33 PM »

NEWSSTAND

The Supreme Court commits suicide

John Nery
May 15, 2018

When the complete history of this Supreme Court is written, the role of Associate Justice Alfredo Benjamin Caguioa as the clarion voice of conscience and clarity in the hardest cases will finally be given sharp relief. As I have learned in the Marcos burial case and in the martial-law-in-Mindanao decisions, Caguioa’s dissenting opinion is the right first read after the ponencia. His dissents — in brisk, bracing language — offer a comprehensive, point-by-point rebuttal (or perhaps the more precise term is evisceration) of the majority opinion; they are messages from an alternate universe, where justice prevails over power and reason over force.

He has done it again, in Republic v. Sereno. He begins with an unflinching look at the true stakes: “This quo warranto petition is brought before the Court purportedly to test the integrity of the Chief Justice. However, what it really tests is the integrity of the Court …. By ousting the Chief Justice through the expediency of holding that the Chief Justice failed this ‘test’ of integrity, it is actually the Court that fails.” (That one word, “expediency,” is telling.)

Linkback: https://tubagbohol.mikeligalig.com/index.php?topic=89593.0
Republic Act 8485 (Animal Welfare Act of 1998, Philippines), as amended and strengthened by House  Bill 6893 of 2013--- violation means a maximum of P250,000 fine with a corresponding three-year jail term and a minimum of P30,000 fine and six months imprisonment

pCloud Premium

islander

  • SUPREME COURT
  • THE LEGEND
  • *****
  • avatar_3258_1429902436 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
  • Posts: 45441
  • medal1 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal2 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal3 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal4 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal5 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
  • If you're from Pluto, you're welcome.
    • Share Post
xx - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
Re: The Supreme Court commits suicide
« Reply #1 on: May 15, 2018, 08:28:28 PM »

He summarizes his view by offering six interconnected arguments, a layered approach to the issue that measures the leap in logic the majority decision had to make. Then he responds to every major argument of the ruling, proving without a doubt that the eight justices who used the case to “re-write the Constitution” (Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio), “supplanting the [Judicial and Bar] Council’s determination” (Associate Justice Estela Perlas Bernabe) and birthing “a legal abomination” (Associate Justice Marvic Leonen), committed institutional suicide. “Without honor,” Caguioa adds.

Years from now, as we sift through the jurisprudential debris of the Duterte era, we will find the charred remains of the Peralta ruling on the Marcos burial and the rotting timber of Tijam’s lengthy justification for ousting a chief justice without benefit of an impeachment proceeding—and then we will see, still standing, the true guideposts. We will be reminded, with the full force of regret, of the legal acuity of Carpio’s opinions, the eloquence and superior understanding of Leonen’s dissents, and the compelling clarity of Caguioa’s alternate — that is to say, true — accounting.

pCloud Premium

islander

  • SUPREME COURT
  • THE LEGEND
  • *****
  • avatar_3258_1429902436 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
  • Posts: 45441
  • medal1 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal2 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal3 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal4 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal5 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
  • If you're from Pluto, you're welcome.
    • Share Post
xx - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
Re: The Supreme Court commits suicide
« Reply #2 on: May 15, 2018, 08:28:59 PM »

For me, the most crucial (and at the same time characteristic) passage in Caguioa’s dissent directly responds to the majority’s dismissal of the fear that the Solicitor General was being given too much power.

“The ‘fear’ is not founded on the ‘fallacious and cynical view of the competence and professionalism of the Solicitor General and the members of this Court.’ … the ‘fear’ is not even based on any imputation of malice or irregularity on the part of the present Solicitor General. Rather, the ‘fear’ is based on the dangerous power the ponencia grants the present and future Solicitors General without any constitutional support. With such unfettered power, the balance of power between the three coordinate departments unconstitutionally shifts, and the independence and stability of the Judiciary is eroded. This is where the danger lies.”

pCloud Premium

islander

  • SUPREME COURT
  • THE LEGEND
  • *****
  • avatar_3258_1429902436 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
  • Posts: 45441
  • medal1 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal2 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal3 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal4 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal5 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
  • If you're from Pluto, you're welcome.
    • Share Post
xx - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
Re: The Supreme Court commits suicide
« Reply #3 on: May 15, 2018, 08:29:39 PM »

Then, three paragraphs later, we read: “The present action for quo warranto against the respondent constitutes an institutional attack on the Supreme Court, as it enlists the Court’s participation in the erosion of its own independence through the circumvention of the very document it has been tasked to uphold.”

Like many others, I am still in shock over the Court’s suicide. It was not unexpected; the signs were there for all to see. Still. I grieve over the role our constitutional law professor, Associate Justice Francis Jardeleza, played in the tragedy—his decision to appear at the impeachment hearings in the House of Representatives had befuddled those of us in the first class he ever taught; but his vote to allow the patently unconstitutional ouster of the chief justice upended everything he taught us in Constitutional Law. I note that in an extensive discussion on Maria Lourdes Sereno’s motion to inhibit six justices who had demonstrated manifest partiality against her, the decision only explained away the conduct of four of the justices; nothing much was said about Jardeleza and about Associate Justice Teresita de Castro. Their damning statements were simply ignored. I read the Tijam decision and see that white is painted as black, and black as white—this is not justice, but, rather, the opposite of it.

pCloud Premium

islander

  • SUPREME COURT
  • THE LEGEND
  • *****
  • avatar_3258_1429902436 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
  • Posts: 45441
  • medal1 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal2 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal3 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal4 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Governmentmedal5 - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
  • If you're from Pluto, you're welcome.
    • Share Post
xx - The Supreme Court commits suicide - Philippine Government
Re: The Supreme Court commits suicide
« Reply #4 on: May 15, 2018, 08:30:03 PM »

It is clear to me and many others that the Court, the one nonpolitical branch of government, must hear back from the people it has failed to serve.

http://opinion.inquirer.net/

pCloud Premium


Share via facebook Share via linkedin Share via pinterest Share via tumblr Share via twitter

xx
Supreme Court in a quandary

Started by islander on Philippine Government

5 Replies
246 Views
Last post March 10, 2018, 02:41:42 PM
by islander
 

Booking.com

Latest Topics

Even If the Worst Thing Happens by MIKELIGALIG.com
[Today at 04:53:32 AM]


Form cheaply vigra no prescription by HozardRoorb
[Yesterday at 03:30:04 AM]


PNP Hiring by MIKELIGALIG.com
[October 14, 2018, 05:37:25 PM]


Wannabes and charlatans on the march by islander
[October 14, 2018, 01:01:51 PM]


Fashion vs No Choice by islander
[October 14, 2018, 06:03:26 AM]


Ang makapahinuklog nga kinabuhi sa usa ka bugtong anak nga lalaki by islander
[October 14, 2018, 05:57:25 AM]


Asa ang hustisya? by MIKELIGALIG.com
[October 13, 2018, 10:43:22 AM]


Please help me understand by islander
[October 12, 2018, 03:38:28 PM]


Avoid the 12 Dangers of Christmas by MIKELIGALIG.com
[October 09, 2018, 03:01:31 PM]


The day after Duterte by islander
[October 09, 2018, 01:18:08 PM]

SMF spam blocked by CleanTalk
pCloud Premium
Powered by SMFPacks SEO Pro Mod | Sitemap
Mobile View
SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2018, SimplePortal