TUBAGBOHOL.com with Ligalig Mike Ortega

Brain Power => Learn English Online => Book Reviews => Topic started by: Lorenzo on November 20, 2007, 03:21:30 PM

Title: The Mexican Revolution 1910-1940
Post by: Lorenzo on November 20, 2007, 03:21:30 PM
From reading Michael Gonzales’ The Mexican Revolution 1910-1940, I realized that one of its flaws was that there was a failure in going in depth in certain topics that were in the book. One example of this was that although the author states that the Mexican Revolution was popular and agrarian-based, he doesn’t support this by not citing specific examples of socio-economic factors. It would have been better had Gonzales given social and cultural accounts of his points by giving specific examples instead of being so wide-scoped in the end. What I mean by this is that Gonzales effectively summarizes the contributions of revolutionary leaders such as Francisco I. Madero, Pancho Villa, Emiliano Zapata, Alvaro Obregon and Venustiano Carranza, as well as President Diaz, but doesn’t go into the socioeconomic factors of these characters. From reading the biography of the book as well as knowing Gonzales was responsible for writing prior works that covered labor as well as economic topics, it was rather disappointing that Gonzales didn’t make reference to those in this book.
I would say that the book’s weakness is its strength, what I mean by this is that it effectively covers amount of history within a limited amount of space, however it is this time constraint that makes the book weak in terms of specifics. Due to such a massive time line covered, it leads to factual errors to manifest, such is observed in page 93 when Gonzales stated that the Bernardo Reyes revolt occurred in 1912, when realistically it began in 1911. These are minor examples of how Gonzales’ broad-aspect focus and evasion of specific detail undermines the work. Essentially, I think that the book would have been better had Gonzales cited more examples and stories that could have strengthened the motives of Zapata, Madero and other revolutionary leaders. 
Powered by SMFPacks SEO Pro Mod | Sitemap
Mobile View
SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2019, SimplePortal